Prime Butcher Shop in Gerritsen Beach, Brooklyn

Open on Gerritsen Avenue since 1927, and still run by the same family. Three generations have worked this counter: custom cuts, USDA prime beef, and a deli case stocked fresh every morning. No shortcuts, no pre-packaged trays, just the old world way of doing it right.

(718) 743-0555 2496 Gerritsen Ave, Brooklyn Mon to Sat, 8am to 6:15pm
A marbled ribeye steak, hand cut, resting on a wooden cutting board

Custom cut, every order

What's In The Case

Everything cut to order, nothing pre-packaged

Glenn and the crew break down whole cuts behind the counter every day. Tell them how thick, how much, and what it's for, and they'll cut it while you wait.

Rows of raw meat cuts labeled and arranged in a butcher's display counter
Beef USDA prime, all natural, no added hormones
Poultry Chicken and turkey, whole or broken down to order
Pork, Lamb & Veal Chops, roasts, and cuts for the grill or the oven
Deli & Salads Homemade salads and hot entrees, made fresh daily
Groceries Everyday pantry staples alongside the meat case
Delivery Free local delivery by refrigerated truck

Our Story

Three generations, one counter

The shop has changed hands within the same working family since Samuel Brenman opened its doors, and the name over the register never came down.

1927

Samuel Brenman opens the shop

A neighborhood meat market on Gerritsen Avenue, built on full-service butchering and a made-to-order counter.

Following Decades

Basil carries the trade forward

The shop stays a working butcher counter through the mid-century growth of Gerritsen Beach and Sheepshead Bay.

Next Generation

Edward Izzo takes over

Edward learns the trade from the ground up and keeps the same standards: hand-selected meat, cut on request.

Today

Glenn Izzo runs the counter

Edward's son Glenn started at the shop at age twelve. He now hand-picks every piece of meat that crosses the case, with over three decades behind the counter.

Catering

Feeding Gerritsen Beach, Sheepshead Bay, Marine Park & Mill Basin

From a family dinner to a full backyard cookout, Brenman's builds catering orders around custom cuts, homemade sides, and the same free local delivery the shop has always offered.

Party trays & platters Custom cut orders for the grill Hot entrees made in house Free refrigerated delivery

Visit The Counter

Stop by 2496 Gerritsen Avenue

Walk-ins welcome. Call ahead for large custom orders or catering so the case is ready when you get there.

Location

2496 Gerritsen Avenue
Brooklyn, NY 11229
Gerritsen Beach

Hours

Mon to Sat8:00am to 6:15pm
Sunday8:00am to 3:00pm

Call The Shop

(718) 743-0555
(718) 743-3600

Call to order